Re: JUDYTH: National Science Foundation scholar****p and grants

On 29 Apr 2008 22:32:59 -0400, jfk297x@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 wrote:

[.....]


>Thanks, Howard.  A welcome breath of fresh air after the thra****ng of 
>Barb's heavy mudslinging.  Do you think she's ready to go back to square 
>one and start with an objective approach toward Judyth? Unlikely as that 
>possibility might seem, it would be much more efficient and productive 
>than the frantic attempts to make something, anything, stick that have,
as 
>you pointed out, backfired magnificently.

If I wasn't objective in the way I am going about seeking verification
of Judyth's claims ... and in presenting all the facts and
cir***stances that I find ... there would be no confirmation that
Judyth ever presented a paper anywhere. 

I could have stopped when I'd exhausted the possibilities for finding
that the IBA ever existed ...which according to state records and
multiple university biology departments .. it did not, Or, when I got
the info from the Academy of Science, I could have sat on that part of
it and not disclosed what I had discovered.

I don't operate that way.

Perhaps you do? Or can we expect you to finally re****t on your
conversation with Mirand? 

You and Martin made big accusations and all kinds of attacks on me
when I re****ted what I had bee told by Roswell Park ...and then
confirmed with a second source before posting it ... that Judyth had
been dismissed from Rowell Park.

Martin rushed to the keyboard to say RP had denied it (which isn't
really what the e-mail he received from the Calif "researcher" said in
the first place) ... telling me I had "been played" and was "toast."
You frothed all over the place indignantly and posting that Mirand
should be confronted with the "do***entation" she had not been
dismissed, but had finished the program in grand style ...and posting
that you had left voice messages for him and would talk to him when he
returned from vacation. Martin promised "details" soon.

Sooo...what do we get?

Now it is *JUDYTH* who confirms Mirand told researchers she had been
dismissed .... and we haven't heard one word from you ... or Martin,
for that matter. What kind of objectivity and research protocol is
that?

Judyth rambled an explanation ... not unexpected.

So, how does her explanation com****t with *all* that was learned from
Dr. Mirand? Are you going to post that info yourself, or wair for it
to filter in from somewhere else???

No need to be shy.You weren't when you were all over me about the
info. Mirand confirmed that info. 

 If Mirand had said she was dismissed but somehow stayed in the
program anyway, finished as a star presenting a great paper and had
awards and a scholar****p from the NSF heaped upon her ... do you
really think anyone believes that you and Martin wouldn't have been
melting your keyboards to get that information posted?

Post *all* the info from the conversation with Mirand.

Now THAT would be a breath of fresh air.