Greg Jaynes wrote:
> On Jul 21, 8:06 pm, "Michael O'Dell" <ml...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
>> For the record.
>>
>> Without disputing in the least, the significance and quality of the wo=
rk
>> Dale has done on the case, he is an authority on the acoustics only as=
it
>> relates to the films. Although he has argued that subset of the issue
>> with Dr. Thomas, it has nothing to do with the claims Don made in his
>> scientific article, so you can't really say Dale pulled the rug out fr=
om
>> under him. As Don Thomas himself has written, that was me.
>>
>> Michael
>=20
>=20
> Michael,
>=20
> As long as it's just for the record.... Not to take anything away from =
you=20
> and the great work you do, I was specifically referring to the last thi=
ng=20
> I read from Mr. Thomas entitled "=93The Bike with the Mike,=94 He seeme=
d=20
> displeased about Myers "Epipolar Geometric Analysis......" study .
>=20
> Mr. Thomas wasn't very scientific in that one. He was just kind of=20
> grousing about how he wished someone more interested would have answere=
d=20
But I already did. He would not have read it here.
> Myers so he wouldn't have needed to. He was repeating Gary Mack's=20
> desperate shoe horning of McLain anywhere he would need to be to keep t=
he=20
> HSCA acoustics alive photographically. I had already heard most of tha=
t=20
> before from Gary before I ever heard of Mr. Thomas. I knew it was=20
> convoluted conjecture. The old "Don't believe your eyes. Believe what I=
'm=20
> telling you" thing.
>=20
> But to bring this to the point you raised, I said no one could have pul=
led=20
> the rug from him like Myers could because a only a month later Myers=20
> responded with a 16,000 word essay entitled "Photographic Proof: H.B.=20
> McLain and Acoustics" This essay included some outstanding illustration=
s=20
> taking Thomas on point by point and answering each charge or claim. Mye=
rs=20
> devasted Mr. Thomas' essay on debating points. No one alive could
have=20
> answered him so thoroughly, convincingly and quickly as Myers did.
>=20
Pretty pictures. Tortured logic. False data.
> Respectfully,
> Greg Jaynes
>=20
|
