Re: A statement from Carol Ann, Mary's daughter, on the "Mary Dean"

Steve Thomas wrote:
> On Jul 26, 11:27 am, Anthony Marsh <anthony_ma...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
>> Steve Thomas wrote:
>>> On Jul 25, 5:02 am, Anthony Marsh <anthony_ma...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
>>>> Steve Thomas wrote:
>>>>> On Jul 24, 9:50 am, Anthony Marsh <anthony_ma...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
>>>>>> Steve Thomas wrote:
>>>>>>> On Jul 23, 10:27 am, Anthony Marsh <anthony_ma...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
wrote:
>>>>>>>> Barb Junkkarinen wrote:
>>>>>>>>> I received this just a few minutes ago.
>>>>>>>>> Carol Ann says:
>>>>>>>>> "Feel free to tell researchers that I did not give material to
Judyth
>>>>>>>>> nor discuss my mother with her. Now that I see what she has, it
is
>>>>>>>>> almost certain that she either picked it up the day she was in
the
>>>>>>>>> house with her sister and me or, possibly, got it out of the
>>>>>>>>> dumpster."
>>>>>>>>> As this solves the "mystery," the papers should be returned to
Mary's
>>>>>>>>> family immediately and taken down from the website.
>>>>>>>>> Barb :-)
>>>>>>>> Got a technical question for you. If you are helping someone move
and
>>>>>>>> he/she asks you to throw something in the dumpster, but instead
you like
>>>>>>>> it and decide to keep it, is that stealing? Or reusing,
recycling? I might
>>>>>>>> remind you of some court cases that decided that once someone had
thrown
>>>>>>>> something away it is fair game for anyone, such as police or
re****ters.
>>>>>>>   I agree with you there Marsh. The problem is Carol Ann said
>>>>>>> "possibly" out of the trash, and that she didnt give Judyth
anything.
>>>>>> I really don't care what excuses Carol Ann made up. The evidence
seems
>>>>>> to indicate that Mary was throwing out the material.
>>>>>   Where do you get the idea that they came from the dumpster?
>>>> As usual for a WC defender you abound in making false charges. I did
not
>>>> say that she took them from the dumpster.
>>>   As usual for someone who believes Judyth's nonsense you cant give a
>>> straight answer.
>>>   "The evidence seems to indicate that Mary was throwing out the
>>> material"
>>>   Where did you get that idea from Marsh?
>> Carol Ann.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>>>> According to Team Judyth specifically Martin, she obtained the Mary
>>>>> Dean "do***ents among some things Mary had given her, apparently
>>>>> inadvertently included."   So where do you get the idea it came out
of
>>>>> the trash?
>>>>>>> So according to her Judyth is already lying. She also said Judyth
may
>>>>>>> have just taken it, which is more likely since she lied 87% of the
>>>>>>> time.- Hide quoted text -
>>>>>> - Show quoted text -- Hide quoted text -
>>>>>> - Show quoted text -- Hide quoted text -
>>>> - Show quoted text -- Hide quoted text -
>>>> - Show quoted text -- Hide quoted text -
>> - Show quoted text -- Hide quoted text -
>>
>> - Show quoted text -
> 
> 
> 
> July 24, 2008 9:50AM Tony Marsh says "I really don't care what excuses 
> Carol Ann made up. "
> 
> 
> July 26 1008 11:27AM Tony Marsh says in respose to my question where he 
> got the idea that Judyth got the Mary Dean do***ents from the trash
"Carol 
> Ann"
> 
> 
>   Talking out both sides your mouth isnt a good thing if you want people

> to take you seriously Marsh. Carol Ann is the only person to say it may 

Carol Ann bringing up the possibility that things were being thrown out is

not any type of excuse that I was pointing out.  Two different topics.

> have come from the trash, but you dont believe her, but you do believe 

Who said I do believe her or don't believe her? She might be right about 
some things and not right about others. She may not even be right about 
throwing away stuff. You just asked me where I heard that.

> her. Can you clear this up for us Marsh? If you dont believe Carol Ann 
> where do you get the idea Judyth got it from the trash? If you do
believe 

I didn't say Judyth got it from the trash.

> Carol Ann you must know she said "possibly got it out of the dumpster." 


Possibly. That's where the idea came from, from Carol Ann.

> AND "it is almost certain that she either picked it up the day she was
in 
> the house with her sister."  So how do you believe and not believe
someone 
> at the same time? How did you pick the "trash" version over the picked
it 
> up the day she was in the house?"
> 

Jeez, are you a kindergartner who thinks that each person always tells the

truth or always lies or is always right or always wrong? She said 
possibly. I accept that as a possibility.

>