Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Alternative > Cyberpunk > Re: William Gib...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 4 of 8 Topic 616 of 677
Post > Topic >>

Re: William Gibson - Pattern Recognition BBC Radio Play

by Kevin Calder <kevin.calder@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Feb 18, 2007 at 04:20 PM

Hello no one.

I finally got around to reading Pattern Recognition, and I thought I'd 
share my thoughts on it with you, the mysterious semi-present population 
of alt.cp.

[spoilers, imho, ymmv e.t.c. y'all know I'm a pomowhore and don't even 
really believe books can be good\bad e.t.c.]

To be honest I didn't particularly enjoy it, but I didn't loathe it 
either, and on both counts I think this is because the whole book is 
just so damn neutral.  The main character, who's particular mutant super 
powers and endless open questions make her seem like an unlively joke 
from *** in the city, just seems like such a dead end.  Actually she 
embodies nothing as sudden, dramatic or extreme as death.  She is more 
like a sleep end. Gibson insists on emphasizing 300 times per chapter 
just how terribly, terribly tired she is and on top of that expends a 
surprising amount of verbiage detailing her going to bed at every 
possible op****tunity.  This is certainly realistic, but its just not 
that interesting and if you set her sitc-mutant power aside, it's the 
second most remarkable thing about her. Which is a shame.  I mean, a 
simple "The next day Casey blah blah blah..."  would have sufficed for 
9/10 bed times.

While Gibson lavishes almost unbearable detail on her sleep and 
sleepyness, disappointingly he also consistently manages to dodge 
detailing anything more interesting.  There don't seem to be any 
interesting ideas in this book at all; rich marketing yuppies drinking 
lattes in starbucks reading their hotmail on their ibooks and getting 
hilariously mixed up in a big misunderstanding with the Russian mob over 
some incredibly dubious plan to distribute some kind of dubious 'high 
art' version of LonelyGirl, it just seemed very bland to me.

But its nicely written.  WG has certainly worked on his prose, and its 
slick and spare and economical and all that, but I think this is part of 
the problem.  I am pretty sure WG is the kind of author who researches 
ideas for his novels, but once he filters this information through his 
now very tightly focused Gibsonian 'lens-o-cool-detachedness' everything 
get stripped down so much that all you get is a few vague (though I 
expect he hopes profound or sublime) evocations, that he only seems 
slightly interested in, and even then only in passing.

I know you don't read Gibson for the exposition, but in the absence of 
exploration of interesting ideas, I'd really like the novel in question 
to be something of a page-turner.

In this respect PR reminds me of the Da Vinci Code, though sadly more 
like the film than the book, i.e. trivial yet dull, rather than 
(allegedly) trivial yet compelling.  Actually I didn't read the book, 
but you've all heard about it so you get the idea.  Why is PR so damn 
slow, and why in all that slowness does nothing very much happen?  I 
think Gibson has become too cool to write anything exciting.  Getting 
excited is pretty much the very opposite of cool detached indifference. 
Maybe.

Anyone else feel the same, or totally different, or hate me and the 
(dead)horse I rode in on, or none of the above, or just plain wish 
*they* were dead?


WG:  Can you power up your eyemac and get someone to show you what 
usenet is so that you can tell me when you are going to reprint a 
version of Necromancer with no spelling mistakes in it??!?!??

[Ok, that was a cheapshot.  Please disreguard.]

[end rant]

Zip,

-- 
Kevin Calder
 




 8 Posts in Topic:
William Gibson - Pattern Recognition BBC Radio Play
"jd" <jdorri  2007-02-12 07:00:11 
Re: William Gibson - Pattern Recognition BBC Radio Play
"jd" <jdorri  2007-02-12 07:03:01 
Re: William Gibson - Pattern Recognition BBC Radio Play
Kevin Calder <kevin.ca  2007-02-18 16:11:54 
Re: William Gibson - Pattern Recognition BBC Radio Play
Kevin Calder <kevin.ca  2007-02-18 16:20:41 
Re: William Gibson - Pattern Recognition BBC Radio Play
Robert Rumble <rbrumbl  2007-02-25 18:08:27 
Re: William Gibson - Pattern Recognition BBC Radio Play
Joseph Brenner <doom@[  2007-08-04 19:27:45 
Re: William Gibson - Pattern Recognition BBC Radio Play
"jd" <jdorri  2007-02-28 02:29:37 
Re: William Gibson - Pattern Recognition BBC Radio Play
Robert Rumble <rbrumbl  2007-02-28 21:08:18 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Thu Aug 21 7:28:20 CDT 2008.