Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Alternative > Legend King Arthur > Re: Sources for...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 3 of 8 Topic 316 of 402
Post > Topic >>

Re: Sources for Gregory of Monmouth (2) - Silchester

by "Malcolm Martin" <pleaseask@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Feb 5, 2006 at 08:27 AM

Patrick

Thanks.

i) Gregory - I could say that I just wanted to check if anyone was 
reading.............but the truth would be otherwise.........Ooops.  Just 
goes to show the truth of the old adage (as do one or two other slips in 
those first two posts) - "before pressing 'send', engage brian"

ii) > But do you suppose Geoffrey's audience knew that Silchester was a 
Celtic
> settlement and never a Saxon one, and for this reason Geoffrey
associated 
> Arthur with Silchester to lend him Celtic credibility

No, probably not.  I think GoM used Silchester because it was in his
source 
(for this early part of his life of Arthur) and also (possibly) because he

knew that it had been a major British centre, and so saw no reason to
change 
this to something bigger or better.

iii) > Also, do you know what actual word Geoffrey used to indicate 
Silchester?

No.  Unfortunately I do not have a Latin copy of Geoffrey, and so when I 
have needed the Latin I have had to ask on the net.   Most frustrating,
but 
I haven't yet been able to pick up a Latin copy of Geoffrey. Maybe in this

group Tom Green <hrothgar_cyning@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> has a copy (or access
thereto) 
and would provide the answer?


> Thanks again for the work you have put into this reply and the breadth
of 
> understanding you present so articulately in this area.

Thanks for that.  Having read it again, once it was posted on to the NG I 
realised there are one or two aspects I should have re-worded to make my 
points clearer, but brian just didn't see them beforehand pressed 
.............'send'......

Kind regards

Malcolm
 




 8 Posts in Topic:
Sources for Gregory of Monmouth (2) - Silchester
"Malcolm Martin"  2006-02-04 17:22:21 
Re: Sources for Gregory of Monmouth (2) - Silchester
patrick boyd <boyd@[EM  2006-02-05 16:03:58 
Re: Sources for Gregory of Monmouth (2) - Silchester
"Malcolm Martin"  2006-02-05 08:27:33 
Re: Sources for Gregory of Monmouth (2) - Silchester
patrickbrown40@[EMAIL PRO  2006-02-28 11:19:42 
Re: Sources for Gregory of Monmouth (2) - Silchester
patrick boyd <boyd@[EM  2006-03-01 05:54:07 
Re: Sources for Gregory of Monmouth (2) - Silchester
"patrickbrown40@[EMA  2006-02-28 16:20:39 
Re: Sources for Gregory of Monmouth (2) - Silchester
patrick boyd <boyd@[EM  2006-03-02 07:47:37 
Re: Sources for Gregory of Monmouth (2) - Silchester
"patrickbrown40@[EMA  2006-03-02 10:59:15 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Sat Oct 11 10:31:00 CDT 2008.